Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
110 lines (74 loc) · 5.12 KB

MAMORA_20250104_091158.md

File metadata and controls

110 lines (74 loc) · 5.12 KB

Project Name: MAMORA

Project Description: Mamora is an AI-powered chatbot that bridges the gap between everyday users and the Solana blockchain—no complicated seed phrases or confusing dashboards required. By simplifying wallet management, balance checks, token swaps, and even mimicking top traders

Project's X/Twitter: https://x.com/mamora_in

Project's Website: https://mamora.chat

Project's GitHub: https://github.com/mamorainc/mamora

Hackathon Submission Analysis: Mamora

Overview

This hackathon submission, titled Mamora, is an AI-powered chatbot designed to facilitate user interactions with the Solana blockchain. It aims to simplify wallet management, balance checks, token swaps, and more, without requiring users to deal with complex seed phrases or dashboards. The project integrates various functionalities, including automated task execution, action API integration, and modular design, making it suitable for developers and users alike.

Main Functionalities and Features

  • Automated Task Execution: Users can perform on-chain actions programmatically.
  • Action API Integration: Connects to external APIs for dynamic operations.
  • Chain Operations: Interacts with Solana smart contracts, manages tokens, and sends transactions.
  • User Management: Handles user sign-up, sign-in, and wallet data retrieval.
  • Chat Functionality: Allows users to send messages and receive bot replies in a conversational format.

Criteria Analysis

1. Correctness

Score: 7/10

Strengths:

  • The codebase appears to be functional, with most core functionalities implemented correctly, such as user authentication, wallet management, and token transactions.

Weaknesses:

  • There are some areas where error handling could be improved. For instance, in the sendSol function, the transaction fee is hardcoded, which may not reflect the actual fee at the time of the transaction: 
    const transactionFee = 5000; // 0.000005 SOL fee buffer
    This could lead to issues if the fee changes or if the user has insufficient funds.

Improvements:

  • Implement dynamic fee estimation by querying the network for the current transaction fee instead of using a hardcoded value.

2. Readability

Score: 6/10

Strengths:

  • The code is generally well-structured, with clear separation of concerns across different files and services. The use of enums for network and status improves clarity.

Weaknesses:

  • Some functions are lengthy and could benefit from breaking them down into smaller, more manageable pieces. For example, the processUserMessage function is quite long and handles multiple responsibilities: 
    async function processUserMessage(
  botReplyId: string,
  userMessageContent: string,
  userId: string,
  chatId: string
) {
  // Function logic...
}
    This makes it harder to follow the flow of logic and understand the purpose of each section.

Improvements:

  • Refactor long functions into smaller helper functions to enhance readability and maintainability. Adding comments to explain complex logic would also help.

3. Bugginess

Score: 5/10

Strengths:

  • The codebase has implemented various functionalities that seem to work as intended, such as user authentication and transaction processing.

Weaknesses:

  • There are potential bugs related to error handling. For instance, in the handleSolanaResponse function, if the function call fails to parse arguments, it returns a generic error message: 
    return `Error: Failed to parse function arguments: ${String(err)}`;
    This could be improved by providing more context about the error.

Improvements:

  • Enhance error handling to provide more informative messages and ensure that all potential error cases are covered. Implement logging for unexpected errors to facilitate debugging.

4. Features

Score: 8/10

Strengths:

  • The submission includes a comprehensive set of features that align with the hackathon's goals, such as wallet management, token swaps, and user interactions through a chatbot interface.

Weaknesses:

  • While the core features are present, there are areas for enhancement, such as adding support for more token types in the swapToken function. Currently, it only supports SOL and USDC: 
    supportedSymbolMintAddr.set('SOL', { /* ... */ });
supportedSymbolMintAddr.set('USDC', { /* ... */ });

Improvements:

  • Expand the token support in the swap functionality and consider adding more user-friendly features, such as transaction history or notifications for completed transactions.

Final Score

Final Score: 6.5/10

Summary

The Mamora submission demonstrates a solid understanding of the requirements and effectively implements a range of functionalities for interacting with the Solana blockchain. While there are strengths in correctness and feature completeness, improvements in readability, error handling, and overall bugginess could enhance the quality of the codebase. With some refactoring and additional features, this submission has the potential to be a robust tool for users looking to engage with the Solana ecosystem.