Slow loading php-fpm configuration

[Munrok]

Description

I've noticed a delay in loading the php-fpm configuration for PHP versions 8.2.X and 8.3.X when there are 250 pools. It takes around 15 seconds for this configuration to load, whereas for PHP versions 7.x, 8.0, and 8.1, it only takes 2 seconds.

PHP Version

8.2.15, 8.3.2

Operating System

FreeBSD 13.2

[iluuu1994]

@bukka I'm not sure if you can comment on FreeBSD specifically (if it is even relevant). If not, feel free to just unassign yourself.

[Munrok]

@iluuu1994 @bukka Is there any update on this matter?

[bukka]

I still don't have working FreeBSD setup (even though I have a laptop with initial install but did not have time to setup all other things there). @devnexen might be able to check it out.

[devnexen]

Hi @Munrok I did the following test with 300 pools and it was pretty fast (and I run freebsd in a VM).

fbsdvbox# ls                                    
pool1.conf		pool127.conf		pool155.conf		pool183.conf		pool210.conf		pool239.conf		pool267.conf		pool295.conf		pool52.conf		pool80.conf
pool10.conf		pool128.conf		pool156.conf		pool184.conf		pool211.conf		pool24.conf		pool268.conf		pool296.conf		pool53.conf		pool81.conf
pool100.conf		pool129.conf		pool157.conf		pool185.conf		pool212.conf		pool240.conf		pool269.conf		pool297.conf		pool54.conf		pool82.conf
pool101.conf		pool13.conf		pool158.conf		pool186.conf		pool213.conf		pool241.conf		pool27.conf		pool298.conf		pool55.conf		pool83.conf
pool102.conf		pool130.conf		pool159.conf		pool187.conf		pool214.conf		pool242.conf		pool270.conf		pool299.conf		pool56.conf		pool84.conf
pool103.conf		pool131.conf		pool16.conf		pool188.conf		pool215.conf		pool243.conf		pool271.conf		pool3.conf		pool57.conf		pool85.conf
pool104.conf		pool132.conf		pool160.conf		pool189.conf		pool216.conf		pool244.conf		pool272.conf		pool30.conf		pool58.conf		pool86.conf
pool105.conf		pool133.conf		pool161.conf		pool19.conf		pool217.conf		pool245.conf		pool273.conf		pool300.conf		pool59.conf		pool87.conf
pool106.conf		pool134.conf		pool162.conf		pool190.conf		pool218.conf		pool246.conf		pool274.conf		pool31.conf		pool6.conf		pool88.conf
pool107.conf		pool135.conf		pool163.conf		pool191.conf		pool219.conf		pool247.conf		pool275.conf		pool32.conf		pool60.conf		pool89.conf
pool108.conf		pool136.conf		pool164.conf		pool192.conf		pool22.conf		pool248.conf		pool276.conf		pool33.conf		pool61.conf		pool9.conf
pool109.conf		pool137.conf		pool165.conf		pool193.conf		pool220.conf		pool249.conf		pool277.conf		pool34.conf		pool62.conf		pool90.conf
pool11.conf		pool138.conf		pool166.conf		pool194.conf		pool221.conf		pool25.conf		pool278.conf		pool35.conf		pool63.conf		pool91.conf
pool110.conf		pool139.conf		pool167.conf		pool195.conf		pool222.conf		pool250.conf		pool279.conf		pool36.conf		pool64.conf		pool92.conf
pool111.conf		pool14.conf		pool168.conf		pool196.conf		pool223.conf		pool251.conf		pool28.conf		pool37.conf		pool65.conf		pool93.conf
pool112.conf		pool140.conf		pool169.conf		pool197.conf		pool224.conf		pool252.conf		pool280.conf		pool38.conf		pool66.conf		pool94.conf
pool113.conf		pool141.conf		pool17.conf		pool198.conf		pool225.conf		pool253.conf		pool281.conf		pool39.conf		pool67.conf		pool95.conf
pool114.conf		pool142.conf		pool170.conf		pool199.conf		pool226.conf		pool254.conf		pool282.conf		pool4.conf		pool68.conf		pool96.conf
pool115.conf		pool143.conf		pool171.conf		pool2.conf		pool227.conf		pool255.conf		pool283.conf		pool40.conf		pool69.conf		pool97.conf
pool116.conf		pool144.conf		pool172.conf		pool20.conf		pool228.conf		pool256.conf		pool284.conf		pool41.conf		pool7.conf		pool98.conf
pool117.conf		pool145.conf		pool173.conf		pool200.conf		pool229.conf		pool257.conf		pool285.conf		pool42.conf		pool70.conf		pool99.conf
pool118.conf		pool146.conf		pool174.conf		pool201.conf		pool23.conf		pool258.conf		pool286.conf		pool43.conf		pool71.conf		www.conf
pool119.conf		pool147.conf		pool175.conf		pool202.conf		pool230.conf		pool259.conf		pool287.conf		pool44.conf		pool72.conf		www.conf.default
pool12.conf		pool148.conf		pool176.conf		pool203.conf		pool231.conf		pool26.conf		pool288.conf		pool45.conf		pool73.conf
pool120.conf		pool149.conf		pool177.conf		pool204.conf		pool232.conf		pool260.conf		pool289.conf		pool46.conf		pool74.conf
pool121.conf		pool15.conf		pool178.conf		pool205.conf		pool233.conf		pool261.conf		pool29.conf		pool47.conf		pool75.conf
pool122.conf		pool150.conf		pool179.conf		pool206.conf		pool234.conf		pool262.conf		pool290.conf		pool48.conf		pool76.conf
pool123.conf		pool151.conf		pool18.conf		pool207.conf		pool235.conf		pool263.conf		pool291.conf		pool49.conf		pool77.conf
pool124.conf		pool152.conf		pool180.conf		pool208.conf		pool236.conf		pool264.conf		pool292.conf		pool5.conf		pool78.conf
pool125.conf		pool153.conf		pool181.conf		pool209.conf		pool237.conf		pool265.conf		pool293.conf		pool50.conf		pool79.conf
pool126.conf		pool154.conf		pool182.conf		pool21.conf		pool238.conf		pool266.conf		pool294.conf		pool51.conf		pool8.conf
fbsdvbox# time /usr/local/etc/rc.d/php_fpm start
Performing sanity check on php-fpm configuration:
[06-Sep-2024 20:51:43] NOTICE: configuration file /usr/local/etc/php-fpm.conf test is successful
Starting php_fpm.
/usr/local/etc/rc.d/php_fpm start  0.00s user 0.37s system 96% cpu 0.379 total
...
root     47700   0.0  0.0  12916  2520  -  Is   19:50     0:00.01 /usr/sbin/cron -s
www      47770   0.0  0.2 168140 20320  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool86 (php-fpm)
www      48023   0.0  0.2 168140 20188  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool168 (php-fpm)
www      48053   0.0  0.2 168140 20252  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool26 (php-fpm)
www      48091   0.0  0.2 168140 20252  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool260 (php-fpm)
www      48574   0.0  0.2 168140 20320  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool86 (php-fpm)
www      48792   0.0  0.2 168140 20252  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool260 (php-fpm)
www      48812   0.0  0.2 168140 20188  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool169 (php-fpm)
www      49403   0.0  0.2 168140 20188  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool169 (php-fpm)
www      49437   0.0  0.2 168140 20320  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool87 (php-fpm)
www      49676   0.0  0.2 168140 20252  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool261 (php-fpm)
www      49797   0.0  0.2 168140 20252  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool261 (php-fpm)
www      49910   0.0  0.2 168140 20188  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool17 (php-fpm)
www      50120   0.0  0.2 168140 20188  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool17 (php-fpm)
www      50157   0.0  0.2 168140 20320  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool87 (php-fpm)
www      50366   0.0  0.2 168140 20252  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool262 (php-fpm)
www      50545   0.0  0.2 168140 20320  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool88 (php-fpm)
www      50731   0.0  0.2 168140 20188  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool170 (php-fpm)
www      50937   0.0  0.2 168140 20252  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool262 (php-fpm)
www      50969   0.0  0.2 168140 20252  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool263 (php-fpm)
www      51055   0.0  0.2 168140 20188  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool170 (php-fpm)
www      51227   0.0  0.2 168140 20320  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool88 (php-fpm)
www      51749   0.0  0.2 168140 20192  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool171 (php-fpm)
www      51757   0.0  0.2 168140 20256  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool263 (php-fpm)
www      51763   0.0  0.2 168140 20320  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool89 (php-fpm)
www      51781   0.0  0.2 168140 20320  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool89 (php-fpm)
www      51818   0.0  0.2 168140 20256  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool264 (php-fpm)
www      51937   0.0  0.2 168140 20256  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool264 (php-fpm)
www      52139   0.0  0.2 168140 20320  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool9 (php-fpm)
www      52348   0.0  0.2 168140 20256  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool265 (php-fpm)
www      52505   0.0  0.2 168140 20192  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool171 (php-fpm)
www      52545   0.0  0.2 168140 20256  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool265 (php-fpm)
www      52672   0.0  0.2 168140 20256  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool266 (php-fpm)
www      52673   0.0  0.2 168140 20320  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool9 (php-fpm)
www      52952   0.0  0.2 168140 20192  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool172 (php-fpm)
www      53272   0.0  0.2 168140 20256  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool266 (php-fpm)
www      53419   0.0  0.2 168140 20192  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool172 (php-fpm)
www      53553   0.0  0.2 168140 20320  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool90 (php-fpm)
www      53630   0.0  0.2 168140 20256  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool267 (php-fpm)
www      53752   0.0  0.2 168140 20320  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool90 (php-fpm)
www      53868   0.0  0.2 168140 20192  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool173 (php-fpm)
www      54192   0.0  0.2 168140 20192  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool173 (php-fpm)
www      54410   0.0  0.2 168140 20320  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool91 (php-fpm)
www      54429   0.0  0.2 168140 20256  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool267 (php-fpm)
www      54589   0.0  0.2 168140 20192  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool174 (php-fpm)
www      54647   0.0  0.2 168140 20192  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool174 (php-fpm)
www      54922   0.0  0.2 168140 20256  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool268 (php-fpm)
www      55206   0.0  0.2 168140 20324  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool91 (php-fpm)
www      55228   0.0  0.2 168140 20324  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool92 (php-fpm)
www      55270   0.0  0.2 168140 20324  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool92 (php-fpm)
www      55275   0.0  0.2 168140 20192  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool175 (php-fpm)
www      55549   0.0  0.2 168140 20256  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool268 (php-fpm)
www      55846   0.0  0.2 168140 20324  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool93 (php-fpm)
www      55964   0.0  0.2 168140 20192  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool175 (php-fpm)
www      56402   0.0  0.2 168140 20256  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool269 (php-fpm)
www      56477   0.0  0.2 168140 20192  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool176 (php-fpm)
www      56559   0.0  0.2 168140 20324  -  I    20:51     0:00.00 php-fpm: pool pool93 (php-fpm)

...

Do you have particular settings you would be willing to share ?

[github-actions]

No feedback was provided. The issue is being suspended because we assume that you are no longer experiencing the problem. If this is not the case and you are able to provide the information that was requested earlier, please do so. Thank you.